Preventing a problem is always easier than dealing with the problem after is has had time to develop.
A combustible dust in an air conveying line can develop a problem very fast and fire prevention is the reason for using spark detection.
Most state governments have adopted into law the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) regulations for fire prevention. These NFPA regulations are very specific about providing spark detection and extinguishment systems for ducts that convey combustible dust. These regulations are also very specific about how the spark detection system must perform.
Detecting, identifying, and hitting a target (spark) moving at over 55 miles/hour is a rather complicated physics problem. Some of the topics that must be addressed are detector sensitivity, detector cone of vision, response time, temperature range, optical obstruction, noise immunity and the degree of spectral matching between the detector and the ember.
Past experience has shown the requirements for intermittent, repetitive application systems. The first is that the detector must not immediately latch into the alarm state with continuous water spray and shutdown. Instead the detector must provide a distinct alarm signal for each ember that passes in view. Second, the input circuitry, which receives the alarm signal, must be able to process the alarm signal such that the extinguishment system solenoid is energized for a time commencing with the alarm signal and ending after the ember has been quenched. Thirdly, the water delivery equipment, that is the solenoid valve and nozzle, must be suitable for intermittent, high-speed operation. At a conveying speed of 5,000 feet/minute, all of the above must be accomplished in less than one second.
Sprinkler systems, which can be less expensive, are not at all suited to the high-speed dynamics of a dust conveying system. Typically a sprinkler system waits for a fire to develop, waits for the temperature to reach 190° F and then responds by flooding the area with hundreds of gallons of water. If the dust filter is located outside and the fire occurs during freezing weather, the clean up can be very time consuming.
The benefits of a high-speed spark detection and extinguishment system are significant:
When clean air is returned from a bag house back into the plant, spark detection takes on a new level of urgency. A fire or explosion in the bag house could send a flame front back into the plant putting both the plant and personnel at risk. A spark detection system equipped with an abort gate in the clean air return can sense the spark and dump the flame front outside before it can enter the plant.